Like I said before, I don't want this to turn into a flame war between the two of us. I have read a lot of your post and know that you are an intelligent person. I am going to pick apart your last post and give my opinion on some of the points you made.
Quote:
By "not that much performance increase" I mean that 7-10 HP is a hell of a lot cheaper to come by with an I/H/E, or a Chip alone. It looks like this swap will run you close to $2K once you count all the nickel and dime parts, paying for services like towing, breaking axle nuts loose, PATS reprogramming, and the like.
|
If you are looking at just the base, then yes you are right. But without a major upgrade to your tranny, you will never be able to add the kind of power you can with a manual. And yes, you most likely spend more than what I have on my estimate of prices. So many variables on where you get the parts. Also, if you are going to have it out, it is a great time to put in upgraded parts like a clutch/flywheel and whatnot. Plus if you break anything you need, you obviously have to replace it. I am sitting at around $1400 for mine, with my upgraded parts and replacing the parts that I have broke.
Quote:
I know our autotragics don't hold up to a lot of abuse, but if you look around, the 5 speeds aren't without their problems
|
I am well aware of this and I hope that people have done more research then just read my write up before they do the swap. I know for example, that the MTX's diff is not all the strong and if you are going to beef up your engine, you better beef up the tranny as well.
Quote:
but unless your car is 100% paid off and 100% out of warranty
|
I couldn't agree more with this statement. If people do do this, the warrenty on the car is gone. No ifs ands or buts about it. Gone! And it isn't something you can put the old one back in if you need to get your car fixed under warrenty!
Quote:
you have a few weeks to sit around and figure it out and get the parts that you need, I don't see how it's practical.
|
Depends. I certainly suggest to anyone even think about this that they should get ALL the parts before they start. That has been one of my mistakes, but then again, I didn't have a write up to go by to get all the parts I needed. I also will say again, that I haven't finished my wiring yet, so I can't tell you how involving that is going to be. Everyone that I have talked to that has done the swap, replaced the main wire harness. This is a very challenging thing to do since you have to disassemble your whole dash. (NOT FUN) and relace virtually every wire. I personally don't think that is nessesary. If I am right, you won't have to replace the main wire harness. That also means that it will not take all that long to do the swap as long as you have the right tools.
Quote:
My reply was mainly for the guy who says he isn't all that great of a mechanic. This swap is most certainly not for everyone. It's not going to be as easy as it looks, guys. This definitely isn't a "bolt-on upgrade".
|
I can appreciate what you are trying to say here. Let me clarify what level mechanicly you should be to do this swap. If you don't feel comfortable remove your transmission, you shouldn't do this by yourself. If you feel that you can take out your transmission, then you should be fine. I am not anywhere close to being a mechanic, but I have done everything on my car. Headers, exhaust, lowering springs, shocks, replacing my blown auto tranny THREE times already. I did it by either following my chiltons/ford service manual or the instructions that came with the part. I was never into cars before I got my Focus. Has this hurt me doing this swap....Yes. I have broke some parts because I couldn't get them out and I had to pay for them. I also don't want to give the wrong impression to early about this though because I haven't finished everything yet. So far, though, everything has been "bolt-on" On the other hand, I took my engine out so I don't know how difficut some of this stuff will be to do with the engine still in the car.
Quote:
In the end, I see this as another pipedream that many people will ponder and stew over, a few will attempt it and succeed, some will attempt it and break something. It's like the honda owners that say they're gonna drop an H22 into their 1979 accord, or the people who see the V8 Focus videos and say they're going to build one too.
|
But don't you realize that alot of the posts on this forums are for peoples pipe dreams? Take the Focus Sport forum. They get hundreds of posts a day, Randy gets countless PMs, Emails, Phone Calls from people that want information on products. How many actually buy? You know, I love this forum because I can usually get the information that I need. Everyone has a picture of what THEY think there car will be like (pipe dreams)Almost everyone would love to throw a Turbo kit for Tom in there car, or a Super Charger from Focus Sport, Jackson Racing, Vortex, or the countless other FI options that are out there. Everyone has those fantasies about one thing or another. So they come here to get the information they need. Let's face facts, most people who bought a Focus, bought it because it was an economical car. Not to pricey. Decent gas milage. What ever. I know that there are people, (like myself) that absolutly love the Focus and don't want any other type of car. But if anyone bought the car because you thought you would just dominate at the local dragstrip, you are in for a rude awaking. You can build up a honda for a whole lot less then you can a Focus. Will this thread be a pipe dream for people. For the majority, yes. But I think you would be surprised at the number of people that have already started to acquire the parts needed. And if only one person every uses the information that I have provided, then it completly worth my time.
Quote:
I can't see stringing along dozens of automatic-driving meeeetoooo fanboys with clutch-foot syndrome
|
I don't see how this would be stringing anybody along. If someone feels confident enough to start, then have fun, here is the information. My Focus is my #1 Hobby. One of the most annoying things that I have been told when I started my research into this was to trade it in and get a mnual. And it may be easier to do that. It may be cheaper to do that. But I love my car. I have so much time and effort into my car that I don't think I could ever have the heart to trade her in. Also, If I trade her in or sell her, odds are that I will have finance the new car. I don't want another car payment!
Quote:
One thing it is, though, is a serious revamp of your car's very essence and infrastructure, and a lot of work.
|
Don't for get that you have to be very commited to do this swap. It isn't very long into the swap where it will be more difficult to stop the swap, reverse, and put the automatic back in. If you are going to do it, and you start it, you will NOT have a choice but to finish it. If it takes you 2 days or a year, you WILL have to finish the swap. Also people, don't get me wrong. I don't think that this is the hardest thing that you can do on the car, but is NOT the easist thing you will do for sure!
Quote:
Sorry if I ruffled a bunch of feathers.
|
Dude, I spent a year in Iraq serving our great nation and helping the Iraqi people have the same options that you do. To freely say what they want to!!! You may ruffle some peoples feathers, but I like your comments. They force me to think even deeper into the "Morality of the Tranny Swap" I hope you don't get offended by any of my comments as I am not by any thing you could say. Unless you talk about my car in a mean way! That would piss me off!!! j/k Thanks again for your input
Patrick